Editorials, Opinions — June 26, 2012 at 6:04 am

Obama’s Immigration Act Needs Further Legislation

Written by

Photo courtesy of msnbcmedia.msn.com

President Obama has issued an executive order which will temporarily halt the deportation of young undocumented immigrants. Under this policy, exemption will apply to undocumented immigrants who are high school graduates, returning war veterans and law-abiding members of society. Eligibility requirements are restricted to current U.S. residents of five years who are under the age of 30 and immigrated before the age of 16. The Department of Homeland Security will allow two years of “deferred action,” which exempts undocumented workers from deportation and provides an opening to obtain legal work permits. The Obama administration states that an estimated 800,000 people will be spared from the threat of deportation and given the opportunity to work under the act.

The Highlander Editorial Board supports President Obama’s initiative for providing temporary relief to undocumented students who wish to pursue employment and education in the land of opportunities. At the same time, we also share the belief that if Obama is willing to enforce a provisional policy towards such a broad and controversial issue, then a much-needed overhaul in immigration reform needs to be pursued. It is pertinent to expand beyond that of a simple political move in creating promised change, which initially landed Obama in the presidential arena.

Support for new immigration policies revived backers of the Development, Relief, Education for Alien Minors (DREAM) Act, which has failed to gain enough Congressional support since its reintroduction in 2009. The DREAM Act would have allowed undocumented U.S. residents to apply for temporary or permanent residency depending upon higher education or military experience.

In a Bloomberg National Poll published June 19, two-thirds of likely voters expressed support for Obama’s immigration policy. Obama has also gained overwhelming support from Latino voters, who made up 9 percent of his votes in the 2008 presidential election.

By taking a position on one of many controversial issues, Obama has sidestepped a polarized Congress in order to inch toward much-needed reform. Despite the obvious political motives with his reelection campaign in full-gear, Obama deserves credit for introducing his political stance and bringing the important issue of immigration back to the forefront of policy discussions.

Eligibility requirements for Obama’s policy still present possible loopholes due to overly specific criterion. For undocumented immigrants who choose to disclose their position by obtaining a work permit, they may be risking deportation after two years if Obama is unable to enact more legal protections. Obama’s preliminary efforts toward immigration reform are applaud-worthy, yet the need for further reform is a must if he’s to adequately fulfill his electoral promises, especially for the sake of undocumented students who risk deportation.

Obama has weaved a rug of political freedom, which threatens to be pulled out from under millions of undocumented U.S. immigrants if proper legislation isn’t made. Obama has the responsibility to show that freedom is not just a temporary possibility, but a permanent reality. To be accepted in a land which offers freedom and opportunity, only to be convicted, prosecuted, and deported in the face of a tattered reform policy will surely reflect poorly on the United States. Obama’s executive order is a step in the right direction towards envisionary immigration reform, but a more comprehensive legislative package is necessary to provide a definite solution.

  • Thomas Bacon

    There’s another way of looking at the problem facing undocumented people from Mexico and South America who live in this country. One that’s a lot better picture then I’ve seen painted. First of all Mexico is not a horrible place. It’s a great country with a lot of cool places and wonderful people. It would be really tough to be deported there if all you knew was the U.S., but it doesn’t have to be like that.
    First lets look some of the positives. With a little cooperation from the U. S. and even the Mexican Cartels, life could look pretty good. First of all many of the undocumented people have been paying taxes and putting money into Social Security that they will never get the benefit of. What if we put some money together to establish a repatriation program along with taking some money we now give to hostile countries, in the name of foreign aid, and establish a carrier path avenue for those who are willing to go to the country of their citizenship?

    Think of the benefit the Southern and Central American countries would get from these, educated, bilingual young people. Think of the opportunity and adventure these young people would have. Their smart, energetic, and the countries need them. They’ve been living here in the fast lane with all the technical toys and tools available to a world power. They could teach, train and encourage the people there and they could create work for them.

    I spent every dime I had running to Mexico and staying there till my money ran out when I was young. I loved it there and loved the people. I know there’s a lot of a problem that we brought on the lower Americas with our thirst for drugs and Nixon’s unwinnable war. But I’d be willing to bet even the Cartel leaders would allow these kids a chance, unmolested, to get a life going for themselves if the right person asked permission. Hell, the Cartels have done more for the town they live near then the Government. I’m not trying to romanticize anything here. I know there’s been a lot of hard things go down. I’ve lived a long time and its been my experience that if you’re minding your own business you’re often left to your business. Unless you get caught in a cross fire and that happens in any war. The U.S. is as guilty of that as any country.

    Im just saying that if it comes to a point that our politicians say that undocumented people have leave then lets not send them alone. Lets send them to a future that brings good feelings and love. Lets at least stand by them and help them. We don’t need any more hard feelings from other countries. We are a generous people and need to demand from our politicians that they represent us as such. Lets paint the picture as one of beauty, hope and prosperity if it has to be painted. Oldmanmike

    • Angel Najera

      In order for you to even suggest such a thing prompts me to think that you’ve only lived the gringo life in Mexico which is totally different than the every day life, you have no idea what is like to live in a country with no future where everyone is corrupted and is just wanted to take advantage of the next person that come through. You are ignorant to think a country like that could change in a matter of years, this has been going on for decades and it will continue as long as Mexico exists. When the first americans came to the promised land the native americans should have send you guys back saying “It’s ok just talk it over a pipe of peace and I’m sure the brittish will understand”

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Robert-Oates/100000977216494 Robert Oates

        you mean like America in 1776

      • AZXyb

        Mexico will remain the corrupt, broken place it is as long as its people are willing to put up with it, and those who are not are willing to live illegally in a country that is not their own, in a land whose citizens do not want them, consigned to live in the shadows like all those who violate the law do, by their own choice, and subject to family separation caused by their own choices. Why don’t the people of Mexico put at least as much effort into reforming and healing their broken government as they put into illegally entering, remaining, working, driving, etc., in the USA? Do they really think that Americans should respect that lawless choice? Or are you saying that the Mexican people are genetically programmed to be corrupt, to take advantage of others? Well, if that’s the case, they certainly don’t belong in the USA, which is a nation of LAWS and functions under RULE OF LAW.

        And the old flea-bitten rant about the British – who were the first Americans – coming to the, OMG! “promised land,” (not that the British set foot in Mexico, or did you mean Virginia and Massachusetts when you wrote of “the promised land”?) isn’t worth a bucket of warm spit. Tell it to the judge.

  • Elizabeth Mendoza

    where do we get more information, as to where do need to go or who do we need to talk to?

  • AZXyb

    Bloomberg is hardly a neutral or expert source. Even the Rasmussen poll, like the Bloomberg poll was poorly worded, eliminating some of the provisions, and giving respondents only the choice to approve either the truncated version (which for many was all they knew about it, having not paid attention, otherwise) or deportation. What ever happened to ethics?

    The headline of this article implies that Obama’s immigration edict is a law, by calling it an Immigration Act. While presidents do certainly have the authority to issue executive orders, they do not have the authority to issue, order, or do anything that conflicts with enacted law or the intent of enacted law. His edict is clearly in conflict with our duly enacted immigration laws and their intent. Congress needs to fortify our immigration laws and see that they are enforced. Illegal aliens have no right to be in this sovereign nation, and contrary to the impression that mainstream media promotes, Americans are NOT in favor of any form of amnesty for illegal aliens.

    If for no other reason (and there are many) Obama needs to be turned out of office for his failure to fulfill his Constitutional obligation to faithfully execute the laws of this nation, and for turning his back on grassroots Americans who do NOT want amnesty, and who do NOT want illegal aliens to continue their unlawful presence in our country, and do want better border security, stronger immigration laws that meet the needs of this nation, and full enforcement of those laws, in favor of illegal aliens and the interests of foreign powers. November 6 cannot come soon enough!