On Oct. 29, U.S. District Judge David Carter rejected a request from the Department of Justice (DOJ) that would have forced election officials to discount 20,000 mail in ballots that it claims were filled in by noncitizens. Carter reasoned that pausing the electoral process would have created stress for voters. 1,355 of these were from Riverside County voters and if the request had been approved, the ballots would have been withheld until the citizenship of the voters could be verified.

The DOJ had initially sent Los Angeles County registrar clerk Dean Logan a thumb drive and a letter in October. In the letter, the DOJ stated that the state had 48 hours to review the list of voters they alleged were “likely” noncitizens and verify the citizenship of each one. Los Angeles County Election officials refused the request due to legal and cybersecurity implications. The Justice Department subsequently filed a lawsuit against the state on Oct. 15. 

Courtesy of Jules Hotz
Courtesy of Jules Hotz

On Oct. 26th, a few days before the ruling, the Riverside County Registrar of Voters received a letter from lead prosecutor Bill Essayli, an acting U.S. attorney and former state assemblymember. In the letter, Essayli asked them to withhold the ballots or be met with further legal action. It read, “Within 48 hours, we ask that you commit to working with DOJ and DHS (the Department of Homeland Security) to identify who on the accompanying list is a citizen and who is not.” 

Michael Cohen, the attorney that represented California in the case, claimed the Trump administration used data “known to be unreliable” to compile the list sent to California officials. The state’s legal team also mentioned that back in July the number of alleged noncitizen voters in the state presented by the Trump administration was 190,000, and that number had dropped to 20,000 by October. 

In a 26 page court order detailing the rationale behind his verdict, Carter wrote that approving the DOJ’s request, “would wreak havoc and disrupt the election that is already underway, create a chilling effect on election workers and voters alike, and discount the votes of United States citizens.” 

Carter also suggested that the DOJ may have been attempting to “set the stage for false claims about elections,” and called for such efforts to stop. 

Other officials have also reported similar analysis. Election law expert and head of the Center for Election Innovation and Research David Becker called the lawsuit “fairly frivolous.”

On Nov. 6, the DOJ asked a federal court to officially dismiss their lawsuit in response to Carter’s ruling. DOJ spokesperson Kiersten Pels has since stated that they are not “backing down” from ensuring ballots are cast only by citizens voters. 

Author